Demeyere vs All Clad Reviews and Comparison – Both Cookware Brands Examined In-Depth
Demeyere vs All Clad, which one is better?
Home chefs need the best tools in order to make tasty meals for their families. Subpar cookware that rusts easily or that suffers from hot and cold spots is no good. What you really want is high-quality stainless steel cookware. That kind of cookware distributes heat evenly and that doesn’t degrade over time.
Fortunately, you have a lot of different choices. Unfortunately, it can be tough to know which top-tier cookware brand you should pick.
Don’t worry – we’ve reviewed and compared two top cookware brands in the industry. Let’s break down All Clad vs Demeyere and see which of the two cookware brands is more worth your time and money.
Demeyere Resto and Atlantis Stainless Steel Cookware Sets Reviews
Demeyere is one of the most well-known cookware manufacturers in the industry. Each piece and cookware set is created in Belgium. This affords the resulting cookware with fantastic quality and durability.
To make sure we perform a good comparison against All Clad, let’s take a look at two Demeyere cookware sets. We'll examine the Demeyere Resto 4-Piece Stainless Steel Mini Dutch Oven Set and the Demeyere Atlantis 6-Piece Stainless Steel Cookware Set.
The Demeyere Resto set is a little more specialized. It's designed to be more budget-friendly. The Demeyere Atlantis set is designed to be higher in quality and a little pricier.
Key Feature #1 - 3-Ply and 7-Ply Stainless Steel Layers
Both sets use alternating layers of stainless steel and aluminum. The Resto Set uses tri-ply stainless steel and aluminum. There's a single layer of heat-conducting aluminum. It's sandwiched between two layers of stainless steel.
The Atlantis Set, meanwhile, uses 7-ply stainless steel and aluminum layers. That’s three layers of aluminum sandwiched between four layers of stainless steel.
Both sets use 18/10 stainless steel, which is among the most durable in the industry. Of the two, the Atlantis Cookware Set is a little more durable overall since it has more stainless steel. Stainless steel is anticorrosive and should last for a long time.
Furthermore, the aluminum in both sets is an excellent heat conductor. It ensures that heat is transferred evenly across the cookware’s surface. Aluminum is also relatively lightweight. So no individual piece is too heavy for comfort.
Key Feature #2 - Matte Bodies and Silvinox Coloring
The sets differ significantly in terms of their finishes as well. Demeyere provides multiple different finishes depending on the line you purchase.
For our examples, the Resto set uses a classic, polished stainless steel finish. The resulting stainless steel has a mirror shine. This looks fantastic at first. But you have to be careful to regularly clean the stainless steel surface. Otherwise, fingerprints and smudges could accrue over time.
The Atlantis set uses Silvinox. This is a silver-white color treatment. It's placed on the stainless steel before manufacturing is complete. It’s long-lasting and helps the Atlantis cookware last for longer without getting finger smudges too easily.
Key Feature #3 - Solid Stainless Steel Handles
Both the Resto and Atlantis Cookware sets use solid stainless steel handles. Both are ergonomically shaped for greater comfort. This is really nice in the case of the Resto set since it has four Dutch ovens to carry around your kitchen.
The stainless steel handles prevent heat from transferring from the pots or pans to your hands. This is true even if the pots or pans have been subjected to heat for a while.
All Demeyere cookware pieces come with a limited warranty. This covers any quality imperfections or problems for 30 years of domestic use or 10 years of professional use.
There is some fine print to be aware of based on the line you choose, however. Thus, this warranty policy isn’t quite as user-friendly as All Clad’s user warranty.
What’s in the Demeyere Cookware Set?
The Demeyere Dutch Oven Classic Cookware Set includes four identical miniature Dutch ovens. Lids are included as well. The Dutch ovens feature a 4.7-inch diameter each. The lids are slightly curved to allow for efficient cooking.
Meanwhile, the Demeyere Atlantis 6-Piece Cookware Set includes:
All Clad D3 and All Clad D5 Stainless Steel Cookware Sets Reviews
All Clad D3 Cookware set
All Clad D5 Cookware set
All Clad is a premium and pricey cookware manufacturer throughout the industry. This manufacturer makes high-quality stainless steel products. They're designed for home chefs that want something built to last even under heavy use.
Let’s take a look at two top All Clad cookware sets: the All Clad D3 and All Clad D5. We summarize the differences here, but we go through in depth here.
Key Feature #1 - Tri-Ply and 5-Ply Stainless Steel Construction
The All Clad D3 Cookware Set uses tri-ply stainless steel construction. This means there’s a single layer of aluminum. It's also placed between two layers of stainless steel. This provides good heat convection alongside good durability and rust resistance.
Meanwhile, the All Clad D5 Cookware Set uses 5-ply stainless steel construction. Two layers of aluminum are sandwiched between three layers of stainless steel. This isn't as much as the seven alternating layers of aluminum and stainless steel found with the Demeyere Atlantis Cookware Set. But it’s still more than enough to provide fantastic durability and heat conduction.
Note that both of these sets use 18/10 stainless steel. This type of steel is supremely durable and long-lasting. It’s the exact same kind still used by Demeyere cookware.
Key Feature #2 - Flared Edges
However, All Clad’s cookware has a slight advantage over the Demeyere sets. Each pot and pan in the above collections comes with flared edges.
This is a minor thing overall. But it adds up to make your cooking experience with All Clad cookware even more enjoyable. The flared edges prevent certain foods like sauce from easily spilling over onto your counter or table. So you might experience fewer messes when using All Clad cookware.
Key Feature #3 - Non-Stick Surfaces
All Clad cookware is also renowned for its fantastic nonstick surfaces. Both the All Clad D3 and All Clad D5 Cookware Sets have nonstick surfaces for each pot and pan in the collections.
Unlike most other premium cookware sets, All Clad uses a special kind of finish to achieve its nonstick effect. This is called a starburst finish. The starburst finish sands down the uppermost layer of the stainless steel cooking surface. This creates a super-smooth texture. This then prevents food from sticking to the stainless steel very effectively.
It’s superior to chemically-based nonstick methods. Chemical nonstick layers can wear down over time and may even be absorbed into your food if you aren’t careful.
Lastly, All Clad’s cookware benefits from a lifetime warranty. Both the All Clad D3 and All Clad D5 have a lifetime warranty for each piece in their collections.
The lifetime warranty covers you from any manufacturer defects. Therefore, you can easily get reimbursed or have a replacement pot or pan shipped to your door if you find something out of order upon ordering one of these sets.
What’s in the All Clad D3 and D5 Sets?
The All Clad D3 Stainless Steel Cookware Set includes:
Meanwhile, the All Clad D5 Stainless Steel Cookware Set includes:
Which Is Better – Demeyere vs All Clad?
The two cookware brands are pretty distinct. Determining which one is best for your needs should be relatively straightforward.
For starters, Demeyere cookware is simply much more affordable compared to All Clad. This includes the All Clad Cookware sets we reviewed above. If you want something good but budget-friendly, Demeyere is definitely the better choice.
However, Demeyere is also great when it comes to heat conduction and overall durability. The Atlantis set we reviewed actually has more layers than the All Clad D5 Cookware Set. Thus, the Atlantis set balances budget and quality better than most other sets.
But the Demeyere Resto Dutch Oven Set is relatively limited in its use. It’s really only a good choice if you need a lot of Dutch ovens for cooking particular dishes.
All Clad’s D3 and D5 Cookware Sets are great choices through and through for all kitchen cooking needs. They include a wide variety of pans and other cooking tools you can use to create a wide range of meals.
Furthermore, All Clad’s D3 and D5 Cookware Sets are made with high-quality stainless steel and aluminum. But they feature additional advantages like flared edges, lifetime warranties, and more.
If you’re in the mood to spend extra money, you can purchase the above All Clad collections with copper cores. Copper cored cookware replaces the aluminum layers with copper. Copper is an even better heat conductor. But you need an interference plate if you want to use copper cookware with an induction stovetop.
Here's the bottom line. Demeyere is a little more budget-friendly and possibly better for specific cooking tasks. All Clad is a better choice if you have extra money to spare and want the best of the best.
All Clad vs Demeyere Cookware FAQs
Are All Clad and Demeyere Cookware Sets Discontinued?
All Clad’s cookware sets are in a bit of a confusing spot. For example, the All Clad D5 Cookware line is officially discontinued according to All Clad itself. Therefore, any All Clad D5 Cookware you find online may be the last of its kind. If you're interested in picking up this line of cookware, you should jump on it while you have the chance.
Once the All Clad D5 cookware is gone, it’ll never come back.
On the other hand, the All Clad D3 Cookware line isn’t officially discontinued. But All Clad isn’t making more of this line at the moment. They may decide to create more of this cookware line in the future if sales pick up. In the meantime, it might still be smart to buy any All Clad D3 cookware you see if you’re at all interested in purchasing it in the future.
Demeyere’s status is also hard to determine. Demeyere still makes the Resto and Atlantis stainless steel cookware pieces described above. But it’s tough to find collections of four and six pieces on their official vendor. You can still find these sets through secondary vendors like Amazon.
For now, it’s best to consider Demeyere’s cookware is officially available. But this may change in the future.
How Do All Clad vs Demeyere Non-Stick Coatings Work?
There’s a big difference between All Clad and Demeyere in the form of their nonstick coatings.
As mentioned, All Clad uses a special starburst finish to achieve the nonstick effect. The starburst finish will last for quite a long time and may never degrade so long as you don’t use metal utensils or put your premium cookware in the dishwasher.
On the flipside, Demeyere uses a traditional chemical coating to achieve the nonstick effect. Specifically, Demeyere uses PTFE coatings. These are chemicals that smooth the cooking surface of the pan or pot they are applied to.
PTFE coatings are officially nonpoisonous according to the FDA. Still, few people want these chemicals to be mixed into their food by accident.
Furthermore, PTFE and similar chemical coatings can wear down over time. If you use metal utensils or expose the cookware to excessive heat, the nonstick effect could diminish. Therefore, All Clad’s nonstick solution is ultimately better. It will last longer and doesn’t have the same risk of wearing down through heavy use.
Are All Clad and Demeyere Cookware Dishwasher-Safe?
All Clad’s premium stainless steel cookware is technically dishwasher safe. But All Clad stresses that you should try to hand wash your cookware whenever possible.
That’s because commercial dishwashers use super hot water and occasionally abrasive detergent. This can eventually degrade the starburst finish that gives each pot and pan their nonstick qualities. You should only ever try to wash All Clad cookware with soft sponges and regular dish soap. Never use a scouring since this can also reduce the effectiveness of the starburst finish.
As non-stick PTFE-coated cookware, Demeyere’s offerings should also be hand washed when possible. The PTFE nonstick coating can withstand dishwashing a little better. But it’s still better to hand wash to prevent your dishwasher from wearing down the time.
This general philosophy is true for any premium cookware you may purchase in the future.
Final Verdict: All Clad vs Demeyere Cookware – Which Should You Choose?
So, which cookware brand is right for you: Demeyere or All Clad?
It’s ultimately up to your budget level and your preferences for things like flared edges or ergonomic handles. Demeyere is still solid choice and the manufacturer has a wide range of different cookware lines to check out. We only examined two in-depth, after all.
But All Clad’s cookware seems to last for a little longer thanks to the quality of its stainless steel. It’s also a better choice if you want your cookware to stay “non-stick” for much longer.
In the end, consider your budget and what you’ll actually use in your kitchen before making your decision. Good luck!